Nancy was selected to the Northeast Region All American Field Hockey team as well as first team All-New England and first team All- Massachusetts State College Athletic Conference in 1986. She also played on the 1985 ECAC-New England championship team. Nancy was a two time NCAA Division 3 tournament team player (1984 & 1986). In 1988, she was elected a member of the American College Athletes Hall of Fame. While at SSC, in 1987, she was tri-captain.